You slip into your superhero costume and the whole town starts losing its mind with you.

The per-criterion detail rests on very few votes per line, so trend rather than certainty. What stands out is a game of writing and tone. The art style, faithful to the show's line, climbs very high, ahead of nearly nine games out of ten. Attachment to the characters follows, ahead of three quarters of the titles. Against that, the one you would take to a desert island stays low, and both the feel with a controller and the soundtrack settle around the middle. The tension is there: you love the world and the tone, but the act of playing leaves less of a mark.

Against turn-based RPGs, this is a case apart: you do not come for the combat system, you come to laugh and for South Park. The engine serves the joke, not the other way around.

So, who is it for? For you if you love blunt humor, references to the show, a world you devour. Much less if you want a deep, demanding combat system first.