A security camera, a pizzeria, and animatronics that move the second you look away.

On gut feel, the community lands it right at the average, ahead of a little under half the games. But criterion by criterion, almost everything tumbles. What you get attached to: right at the bottom, ahead of barely 4% of games, and on enough votes for the verdict to hold. What you'd take to a desert island: lower still. The soundtrack, the art style, the feel in your hands: all in the bottom third, though the controller side rests on only a few votes and is one to confirm. Only rediscovery keeps its head a touch above average. That's the tension: you remember it, you recognize it on instinct, yet none of these attachment or aesthetic measures work in its favor.

Which makes sense, really. It's a scare machine, short and tense, built for the jolt and the dread, not for long-haul attachment or beauty.

So, who's it for? For you if you love raw fear, the anxiety of surviving one night, a thrill to share. A lot less if you want a world to bond with and art direction that sweeps you away.