Eorzea is not a game you finish, it is an address you end up living at.

And the community profile says exactly that. For the desert island, Final Fantasy XIV sits ahead of 98% of games. The late-night fun, the one you start "just for a quick session" before watching the sun come up, sits at 96%. The wish to discover it fresh again, 98% as well. Attachment follows right behind, ahead of 89% of titles. Then comes the line that breaks the pattern: controller feel drops it to the very bottom of the rankings. That is the real tension here. People love it for the world, the friends, the stories, the sheer duration, almost never for the immediate feel of the inputs. The soundtrack scores very high but on only two duels, so it needs confirming, just like the art style trailing far lower on just as few votes.

For an MMO, this is a coherent profile. These games do not win on combat snappiness, they win on what they build around you, month after month. Few solo RPGs can claim a rediscovery score like that.

So, who is it for? For you if you want a world to come back to, a community, a long-haul story and a soundtrack that follows you around. Much less so if you want combat that lands hard from the first minute.