Hordes of demons, raining loot, and that hypnotic click you can't put down.

Diablo III's profile pulls in two opposite directions. Up top, the desert island, ahead of two thirds of games, and fun, ahead of nearly two thirds too, though these early votes stay fragile. At the bottom, two lines that surprise for a Blizzard title: rediscovery, near the very bottom with only 17% of games behind it, and sound, barely better. Attachment sits in the middle. The tension is right there: a game you'd happily take along, gladly relaunch, but few dream of living again for the first time. Fitting for a hack and slash: the magic is in repetition, not surprise.

Against the dungeon crawler greats, Diablo III owns its loop: kill, collect, repeat. It's not a game of narrative emotion or a memorable soundtrack, and the criteria say so bluntly.

So, for who? For you if you love the catharsis, the satisfying farm, the session that drags on without you noticing the clock. Much less if you want an OST that haunts you or a world you'd want to discover untouched.