Gotham seen from Bruce Wayne's chair, with a file to open and a conscience to negotiate with.

On gut instinct, with no criterion, the community places it a little below average, without rejecting it. The criterion detail explains why. Attachment holds up, so does art direction, both around mid table, proof that the character and the linework still land. But the feel with a controller in hand drops to the very bottom, close to last, with fun right beside it. There is the tension: you get attached to what it tells you while barely playing it. The soundtrack sinks too, though on only two votes, so treat that as unconfirmed.

Compared to other Telltale games, the logic is identical: story first, hands later. Against an action Batman game the gap is structural, it is simply not the same craft. What these questions do not capture is the weight of a choice made in ten seconds.

So who is it for? For you if you love dilemmas, dialogue, a Bruce Wayne who matters as much as the mask. Much less so if you want the game to answer back under your fingers.